Posted in

How to Contest a Will: Grounds, Who Can Contest, and the Process

Photo by Katrin Bolovtsova on Pexels

Contesting a will means formally challenging its validity in probate court after the person who made it has died. It is not the same as disagreeing with the will, or feeling the split of property was unfair. A court will only hear a challenge from someone with legal standing, and only on specific legal grounds — for example, the will maker lacked mental capacity, was pressured into signing, or the will was not signed and witnessed as state law requires. Most wills are never challenged: by one estimate, about 99% pass through probate without a hitch. When a challenge is made, though, deadlines are short and costs are high.

What It Means To Contest A Will

A will contest is a lawsuit asking the probate court to declare a will, or part of it, invalid. The person who made the will, known as the testator, has died, so the court cannot ask them what they intended. Instead, the judge examines the document, the circumstances of the signing, and the evidence each side presents.

A contest must show something was legally wrong with how the will was made, not simply that the outcome is unpopular.

Who Can Contest A Will

You cannot challenge any will. You must have legal standing — you must be an interested party whose own inheritance would change if the will were thrown out. Courts generally recognise standing for:

  • Heirs under intestacy law. If there were no will, state law would decide who inherits, and a close relative who would inherit under those rules has standing, even if the will leaves them nothing.
  • Beneficiaries of an earlier will. If an older will left you more, you can challenge the newer will, because you stand to gain if it is set aside.
  • Beneficiaries of a later will. If a will made after the one in probate exists, someone who benefits under it may also have standing.
  • Beneficiaries of the current will. Even someone named in the will being probated can challenge it, for example if a later amendment was forged or forced.

Standing alone is not enough; you still need a valid ground and evidence.

Grounds For Contesting A Will

A will contest in probate court
Photo by Sora Shimazaki on Pexels

Courts accept only a small set of reasons. They come down to three questions: was the will maker able to make a will, does the document meet state law, and did someone interfere?

Lack Of Testamentary Capacity

The person who made the will must have been of sound mind when they signed it. This is not a demanding standard. A court usually only requires that the will maker knew what a will does, understood in general terms what property they owned, and knew who would normally inherit from them.

That bar is deliberately low, and it surprises many families. Forgetfulness or confusion does not by itself prove a lack of capacity. A person must have been seriously impaired at the exact time the will was signed. Courts usually weigh medical records, witness testimony, and accounts from people who saw the testator near the signing date.

Undue Influence

Undue influence happens when someone in a position of trust pressures or manipulates a vulnerable person into making a will that reflects the influencer’s wishes rather than the testator’s own. A common pattern is a caregiver or adult child who isolates the testator, controls visitors, and then benefits from a sudden change to the will.

Proving it is difficult. The court looks for vulnerability through age, illness, or dependence, an influencer with the opportunity and motive to exert control, and a will that sharply breaks from the testator’s earlier wishes while mainly benefiting the influencer. Suspicion alone is not enough.

Fraud Or Forgery

A will can be declared invalid if it was obtained by fraud or forgery. Fraud might mean the testator was tricked about what they were signing — for example, told a document was a power of attorney when it was really a will. Forgery means the signature is not the testator’s at all.

Improper Execution

Every state sets formal rules for how a will must be made. Most states require the will to be in writing, to state expressly that it is the maker’s will, to include at least one substantive provision such as leaving property to someone, and to be dated and signed before at least two adult witnesses. In most states, witnesses should not be people who inherit under the will.

One exception is the holographic will, written entirely or partly in the testator’s own handwriting. Holographic wills are valid in about half the states, even without witnesses, but they must still be signed, and the court must be satisfied the document is genuinely in the deceased person’s handwriting and was intended as a will. Because there are no witnesses, they are challenged more easily.

A Later Valid Will

If the testator made a newer will that meets all legal requirements, it generally replaces the older one. A contest can therefore rest on proving a later will exists and is valid.

Being Left Out Is Not A Ground

Being disinherited, or receiving less than a sibling, is not by itself a ground to contest a will. The court’s question is whether the will is legally valid, not whether it is fair. A contest built only on unfairness will fail — and it can still cost a great deal in legal fees.

How To Contest A Will: The Process Step By Step

The will contest process
Photo by Ekaterina Bolovtsova on Pexels

The exact steps vary by state and local probate court rules, but the general sequence is similar across the United States:

  1. Get a copy of the will and the probate filing. Find out what was submitted to the court, when it was admitted to probate, and who the executor is.
  2. Talk to a probate litigation attorney. An initial consultation can tell you whether you have standing, whether any ground applies, and what it will likely cost.
  3. Gather evidence early. Useful evidence includes medical records from around the signing date, earlier versions of the will, and witness accounts. Evidence gets harder to collect as time passes.
  4. File the contest with the probate court. This is usually a petition stating who you are, your standing, the grounds, and what you are asking the court to do. The executor and other interested parties must be notified.
  5. Go through discovery and hearings. Both sides exchange documents, give testimony under oath, and may call expert witnesses. Many contests settle or go to mediation here rather than reaching trial.
  6. Receive the court’s decision. At trial, the judge (and in some states a jury) decides whether the will is valid. If it is upheld, probate continues under its terms. If not, the court decides what governs instead.

How Long Do You Have To Contest A Will

Deadlines are set by state law and are typically short — usually a few months from the point the will is admitted to probate. Missing the deadline generally means losing the right to challenge, even with a strong case.

Two examples show how much the limit varies. In California, a contest generally must be filed within 120 days (around four months) after the will is admitted to probate. In Illinois, the limit is six months after admission. Check the probate court’s rules in the state where the will was filed as soon as probate opens, and act well before any deadline you find.

What Happens After You File A Will Contest

Filing a contest usually slows or pauses distribution, because the court cannot safely hand out property under a will whose validity is in doubt. The possible outcomes are:

  • The will is upheld. The contest fails, and probate continues under the will’s terms.
  • The will is invalidated in whole. The estate is then generally distributed under an earlier valid will, if one exists, or under the state’s intestacy laws if no earlier will survives.
  • The will is invalidated in part. If only a clause or amendment is found invalid, the rest of the will may still stand. A codicil is a formal amendment to a will and must meet the same execution requirements as the will itself. You can read more about how codicils work in What Is A Codicil?
  • The case settles. Many will contests end in a negotiated agreement, often through mediation, in which the parties agree on a division of the estate rather than letting the court decide.

No-Contest Clauses: The Risk You Must Check First

Before filing anything, check whether the will contains a no-contest clause. Such a clause says that anyone who challenges the will loses whatever inheritance the will gave them. In about half of the states, courts will enforce these clauses, so a beneficiary who contests and loses can end up with nothing — even the share the will originally promised them.

That does not mean it should automatically stop you. Some states refuse to enforce them, others enforce them only when the challenge was brought without probable cause, and a person left nothing by the will has nothing to lose under the clause. Weigh that risk with a lawyer before filing.

Is Contesting A Will Worth It?

Honest answer: often, no. Courts start from the position that a will that looks properly made is valid, and the challenger carries the burden of proof. Litigation is expensive, and the process can take months, during which the estate is largely frozen. There is also a personal cost: will contests are usually family disputes that can permanently damage relationships.

A contest can still be worth pursuing when the evidence is strong and the stakes are high — for example, where a vulnerable parent’s will was changed shortly before death to benefit one caregiver, or where a signature is plainly forged. Get an honest assessment from a probate litigation attorney before committing.

A living trust is generally harder to challenge than a will, and assets held in a properly funded trust pass outside probate altogether. You can read about the benefits of a living trust and how a will differs from a trust to understand the alternatives.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Anyone Contest A Will?

No. Only someone with legal standing can contest a will, generally an heir under intestacy law, a beneficiary of an earlier or later will, or a beneficiary of the current will.

How Much Does It Cost To Contest A Will?

There is no fixed price. Costs vary widely by state, by the complexity of the case, and by how far it goes. Contested probate litigation is generally expensive, involving attorney fees, expert witnesses, and court costs.

Can You Contest A Will After Probate Has Closed?

Usually not. Once the deadline set by state law has passed, or the estate has been fully distributed and probate closed, a challenge is generally too late.

What Evidence Do You Need To Contest A Will?

It depends on the ground. Lack of capacity typically relies on medical records and witness accounts from the time the will was signed. Undue influence relies on evidence of vulnerability, isolation, and control. Improper execution is usually shown from the document itself and the witnesses’ accounts.

The Bottom Line

Contesting a will is possible, but it is a narrow remedy with strict limits. You need standing, a recognised ground, and you need to act within a short deadline set by state law. If you believe a will does not reflect the deceased person’s true wishes, get the probate filing, speak to a probate attorney quickly, and gather evidence while it is still available.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Probate and will-contest rules vary by state, and individual circumstances differ. Consult a licensed attorney in the relevant state for advice about your specific situation.

Oliver is the founder and editor of 5E Magazine (5emagazine.com), an online magazine covering celebrity news, lifestyle, health, law, travel, technology and home improvement. He publishes practical guides, explainers and trending stories in simple, easy-to-read language for everyday readers. For questions, corrections or story tips, you can reach the 5E Magazine team at info@5emagazine.com.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *